Knol: About.com and NOT the Wikipedia Killer


Recently Google announced the public availability of Knol, after a test run of around 7-8 months. Most of the people see it as Wikipedia killer. Though there are similarity between Knol and Wikipedia, there are noticeable difference as follows -


  • The first difference is that Knol is all about articles and not creating encyclopedia. Wikipedia is more subject/topic centered whereas Knol is more article/ author centered.
  • Author can still own the copyright of the article and decide whether s/he wants contribution from others or not. He has also few license options available to choose from. Option for selecting license is not possible with Wikipedia.
  • One major difference that I see it the option for monetization. I had written one post previously that Twitter and FriendFeed should allow monetization, so why not Wikipedia? Google approach definitely encourages sharing and collaboration by adding monetization aspect to the contribution.
  • All articles in Knol is having nofollow attribute, so there will not be an impact on the page rank of the hyperlinked page. Though the link to your blog/ website will not affect PageRank, still you may expect increase in traffic.
  • Knol puts strong emphasis on trust and they have a verification mechanisms. They recommend name verification by telephone or by credit card.
I personally feel that there are more difference than similarity in Knol and Wikipedia. They cater to two different markets and I believe there is sufficient scope for co-exist rather than killing each other.

Instead of Wikipedia, I believe that Knol has more similarities with About.com. If you don't know, About.com is a portal where you can get articles on various topics written by prominent authors. Generally all those articles are paid articles and About.com pays to the authors. Seeing Knol's article centric approach, I believe that conceptually Knol is very much similar to the About.com. I would prefer calling Knol a "Web 2.0 About.com".

About.com doesn't give reader of the article any method to contribute to the article similar to Wikipedia. Neither it does allow everybody to publish new articles in different categories. So the contribution is very much restricted in About.com. Knol.com takes the idea of About.com, fixes contribution issue and also incorporates monetization which again promotes contribution. The emphesis on contribution is what makes it "Web 2.0".

I am not saying that Knol.com is going to kill About.com. In fact, in my opinion, there is good possibility for co-existence of all three websites - Knol, Wikipedia and About.com. Though I am saying that Google has made About.com available to everybody and we will definitely see excellent knowledge base in future.

Thanks Google.

Comments

CG said…
I don't think Knol will be a success the way it presently stands. This is an uncooked product that Google didn't fully test before releasing.

Check out my 2 words on knol at my blog
July 30, 2008 at 11:35 AM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Rediff, Indiatimes, Yahoo Ad-Rates for Online Advertisement

Image
Today I was searching for advertisement rates of online ads. I was primarily interested in some of the big portal names like yahoo, indiatimes, and rediff etc. It took quite a while to come up with the search results having all these figures. I found two articles having some information and thought sharing with you - Business World Exchange4media Exchange4media article was written in 2004, so slightly outdated. Business World article is of year 2007 and gives sufficiently latest information. Here is the summary from the Business World article -
Read more

Use your Mobile Phone as Webcam - New Lag Free Solution

Image
This is a new lag free solution that I didn't find on Internet. Most of the solutions currently available recommends DroidCam, IP Webcam, iVCam, NDI, Open Live Streaming apps etc. None of these solutions were able to give me better than Webcam quality with lag free output. With my solution, you can get DSLR like quality (depending upon your mobile phone) and use your mobile phone as high quality web cam. Use it with OBS, Zoom, MS Teams or software of your choice. NOTE - 1. This solution has been only tested with Android phones and I have yet to test it on iOS (iPhone / iPad). 2. This solution works only on high-end Android phones which support output over USB Type-C port. My solution overview - Now a days most of the phones do have USB Type C port and Video output over USB Type - C. My solution is to capture this output with a wire (to ensure high quality lag-free output) and give it as input to your computer. Once your computer gets it as camera input, you can use any software
Read more

Switch Back to Old Facebook Design

Image
Facebook has once again become the center of criticism of its users. This time the bone of contention is its new design. Around 1.7 million users worldwide are not happy with it and they’ve formed this group to show their disapproval. Actually, the new design of Facebook is meant to give the Twitter feel and provide more space for advertisements. New and old design, both have their pros and cons. But as far as Facebook is concerned, it has ridiculed the demand of switching back to older one. But if you have become habitual of the older design and want to keep using that, here’s an easy trick for you. You can get your dear old Facebook back in just three easy steps: Add the “Facebook Developers” application ( from here ) Click on “Go to application” and close the page Follow this link It’s simple, isn’t it? Those who adore older Facebook should try it out. Although, I rather prefer the new design myself. (Courtesy: www.hindi2.com )
Read more